Gibbs paradox is shown to arise from an incorrect traditional definition of the entropy that has unfortunately become entrenched in physics textbooks. Gibbs paradox from eric weissteins world of physics. The gibbs paradox has frequently been interpreted as a sign that particles of the same kind are fundamentally indistinguishable. Two versions of the socalled gibbs paradox are discussed. Entropy of identical and distinguishable particles. By adopting boltzmanns definition of the entropy, the violation of the second law is eliminated, the properties. In a simple derivation based of the ideal gas law, the entropy s is not an extensive variable as it must be. We show in this note that gibbs paradox arises not due to application of thermodynamic principles, whether classical or statistical or even quantum mechanical, but due to incorrect. Click here to start a new topic please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes new to wikipedia. Pdf gibbs paradox is shown to arise from an incorrect traditional definition of the entropy that has unfortunately become entrenched. Fundamentalism, antifundamentalism, and gibbs paradox 159 increases also when like substances mix. The gibbs paradox towards an axiomatic approach just. Statistics of distinguishable particles and resolution of.
The gibbs paradox involves the contrast between mixing two quantities of ideal gases of a di. Also, there are particles in the volume and particles in the volume. Gibbs paradox is based on a traditional definition of the entropy in statistical mechanics found in most textbooks 46. There are several famous variations on what gibbs originally wrote, so i will take the. The entropy change should be zero and essentially is zero, in the correct theory that takes the indistinguishability into account because the thin membrane doesnt materially change the system.
Among its flaws, the traditional definition predicts a violation of the second law of thermodynamics when applied to colloids. The difficulty is resolved by letting the particles be. There is another version of gibbs paradox that involves the mixing of two gases, which i will discuss in the third section of this paper. The gibbs paradox in statistical mechanics is often taken to indicate that already in the classical domain particles should be treated as fundamentally. Willard gibbs 1875 contains a correct analysis of the gibbs paradox about.
View gibbs free energy ppts online, safely and virusfree. The paradox in which there is an increase in entropy when two separate volumes of gases of the same kind, at the same temperature. Pdf the gibbs paradox and the physical criteria for. The inextensivity leads to the socalled gibbs paradox in which the mixing entropy of two identical classical. Explanation of the gibbs paradox in statistical mechanics.
Adapted from answer to what are the weirdest science paradoxes that are mathematically true but counterintuitive. Pdf the gibbs paradox is essentially a set of open questions as to how sameness of gases or fluids or masses. The gibbs paradox one of the important tasks of thermodynamics is the study of mixtures and mixing processes. Based on a reconsideration of the gibbs paradox, we show that a residual, nonextensive term in entropy turns up upon mixing identical particles, whether they are indistinguishable or not. This state of affairs is presented in the textbooks of statistical mechanics as gibbs paradox. Gibbs paradox and plancks experiment on the reversible mixing of gases provide evidence of this in two typical instances. Probably the most interesting aspect of this task is the gibbs paradox. Pdf gibbs paradox and the definition of entropy researchgate. Why did gibbs fail to give this explanation in his statistical mechanics. Gibbs paradox and the definition of entropy ttu physics. The gibbs paradox in statistical mechanics is often taken to indicate that already in the classical domain particles. The gibbs paradox towards an axiomatic approach by aniket sudeep dalvi and chinmaya bhargava abstract we discuss the gibbs paradox in statistical mechanics from an axiomatic perspective. The gibbs paradox is essentially a set of open questions as to how sameness of gases or fluids or masses, more generally are to be treated in.
This is not a forum for general discussion of the articles subject put new text under old text. Pdf explanation of the gibbs paradox in statistical. The gibbs paradox seems less virulent, because the distinction between identical particles and nonidentical particles is an inherent feature of quantum mechanics itself. It is assumed that the number density is the same throughout the system figure 2.
In this letter, it is argued that the correct counting of microstates is obtained from the very beginning when using newtonian rather than laplacian state functions. Versteegh1,2 and dennis dieks1 1institute for history and foundations of science, utrecht university, p. The gibbs paradox and the physical criteria for the indistinguishability of identical particles. Gibbs paradox article about gibbs paradox by the free. The gibbs paradox involves the contrast between mixing two quantities of ideal gases of a different kind and that of mixing two quantities of the same gas. Willard gibbs 1875 contains a correct analysis of the gibbs paradox about entropy of mixing, free of any elements of mystery and directly connected to. In statistical mechanics, a semiclassical derivation of the entropy that does not take into. A partition separates the container into two sections with volumes and, respectively, such that. Gibbs paradox why should the change in entropy be zero. Consider an ideal gas of n particles in a container with a volume v. Introduction it has always been believed that gibbs paradox embodied profound thought, schrodinger 1. The gibbs paradox is essentially a set of open questions as to how sameness of gases or fluids or masses, more generally are to be treated in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics. Statistics of distinguishable particles and resolution of the gibbs 787 that the gp1, contrary to popular belief, is by no means only a problem of classical statistical mechanics, but may very well occur for. Discussions of gibbs paradox tend to be fairly abstract.
The resulting entropy then agrees with the empirically tested thermodynamic. Gibbs paradox in the context of statistical mechanics addresses the issue of additivity of entropy of mixing gases. The gibbs paradox and the distinguishability of identical particles marijn a. Pdf a note on gibbs paradox radhakrishnamurty padyala. Gibbs entropic paradox and problems of separation processes. Plancks experiment on gas mixing, gibbs paradox and the. The gibbs paradox has frequently been interpreted as a.
One can explain the gibbs paradox in statistical mechanics in the sa me way. My hand written class lecture notes are being scanned and uploaded for you to view. Redhead gibbs paradox and nonuniform convergence it is only when mixing two or more pure substances along a reversible path that the entropy of the mixing can. The gibbs paradox of the first kind gp1 refers to the false increase in entropy which, in statistical mechanics, is calculated from the process of combining two gas systems s1 and s2. During the last 150 years, many physicists and specialists. Demonstration and resolution of the gibbs paradox of the rst kind 2 1. In fact the gibbs paradox is a special case of the mixing paradox which contains all the salient features. A closely related paradox to the gibbs paradox is the mixing paradox.
Maximum entropy principle, equal probability a priori and. In short, quantum theory did not resolve any paradox, because there was no paradox. Fundamentalism, antifundamentalism, and gibbs paradox. Demonstration and resolution of the gibbs paradox of the. This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the gibbs paradox article. Gibbs paradox actually, the idea of dividing the partition function of n particles by n. This letter presents a new, solely thermodynamical argument for considering the states of the quantum isolated horizon of a black hole as distinguishable. Most versions of gibbs paradox, including the one i give in this section, rest on the fact that eq. Gibbs paradox, amagats law, daltons law, ideal gas mixtures, entropy change 1. It is show that the gibbs paradox is actually paralogism, viz.
The gibbs paradox and the distinguishability of identical. Willard gibbs 1875 con tains a correct analysis of the \gibbs p arado x. Entropy free fulltext on the socalled gibbs paradox. Introduction the gibbs paradox is about entropy of mixing gases. The gibbs paradox results from analyzing mixing entropy as if it was a type of thermodynamic entropy.
1231 1013 997 1473 233 415 1478 1368 1511 348 228 795 393 281 1352 1128 1097 1454 488 1126 1485 1238 1280 894 778 1302 366 725 217 954 703 505 283 895 698 1 128 991 492 245 1227 71 834 1181 1279 1062 142